Swimming Pool Service Cleaning Company l Blue Waters Pool Services

Swimming Pool Guides & Reviews by Certified Pool & Spa Operators

Best Pool Cleaner of 2019

Here are the best cleaners out on the market.

1st Place

uction Pool Vacuum (Automatic Pool Cleaner)

AquaNaut PHS41CST

Flawlessly navigates any surface



Runner Up

Hayward Poolvergnuegen

Pool Cleaner Automatic Suction Pool Vacuum, 2-Wheel, White



Runner Up

Polaris 3900 Sport

pressure side pool cleaner



How We Found the Top Automatic Pool Cleaners

swimming pool test

18 brands

pool lab guide

62 hours of

testing pool equipment

4 top picks

Do you need to find the best cleaner available? We realize there are a lot of choices out there, so it is important that you make a wise investment and pick one that is right for you. To help you figure out which is the best, we’ve conducted all the difficult research for you.

Below is a list of the top 13 best automatic cleaners of 2019. They’re made by some of the top brands and companies in the industry. Many of them are premium quality cleaners that are best sellers and priced affordably. You’ll find all different types of cleaners to accommodate pools of any shape and size. If that isn’t good enough, then you’ll be happy to know that these cleaners have received positive ratings from other pool owners like yourself. They can vouch for how well these cleaners have cleared out the debris in their pool easily and automatically.

Now, let’s look at these amazing cleaners.

swimming pool cleaners

1. Hayward PHS41CST AquaNaut

uction Pool Vacuum (Automatic Pool Cleaner)

Automatic Cleaner

Flawlessly navigates any surface


  • Produces power at any flow to manage any debris without clogging
  • Manages continuous suction on uneven surfaces and obstacles
  • Multiple pre-programmed steering sequences
  • Designed with 4-wheel fordeep ends


  • It comes with a short warranty of 1 year

Why we chose it

The Hayward AquaNaut Suction Cleaner is like a 4-wheel drive tank which plugs into your pool pump and uses its suction power to clean the water. A lot of pressure-side cleaners require you to use a booster pump, but that is not the case with the AquaNaut Suction Cleaner. You simply plug it into the existing pump, and that is it. As the cleaner circulates through the water, it will clean both the shallow and deep ends.

You can use the AquaNaut Suction Cleaner for both large pools and small pools. There are 3 throats available to handle debris of all different sizes. The suctioning power can also be adjusted to different levels too. This is great if you have a variable rate pump to use with it.

Let’s review its main features:

An Adjustable Roller Skirt

The Aquanaut Suction Cleaner has an adjustable roller skirt which keeps its cleaning power consistent when it travels over surfaces that are not even. For instance, if the cleaner approaches an obstacle in its way, the roller skirt makes an adjustment to cover the obstacle while sustaining most of the suctioning power.


The Aquanaut Suction Cleaner has 3 throats that are interchangeable. This means you can customize the throats to handle different flow rates and debris sizes if you have variable speed pumps. A lot of suction-side cleaners find it challenging to meet minimum flow requirements. But because of the interchangeability of the throats, the Aquanaut cleaner can avoid this problem.

4-Wheel Drive

The Aquanaut Suction Cleaner has 4-wheel drive capability. This gives it the extra ability to climb over uneven surfaces and obstacles, such as drains, without any setbacks. If you have a sloped surface in your swimming pool, then you will benefit from this cleaner. Steep slopes and deep water are okay too, which are things that a lot of other cleaners have trouble with.

V-Flex Technology

The Aquanaut Suction Cleaner is built with something called V-flex technology. With this technology, it can suck up big pieces of debris through its suction tube, and it won’t even get caught in there. This is quite handy for anyone who gets a lot of big leaves and fine particles in their pool water. Now you don’t need to worry about the tube getting clogged ever again.


The Aquanaut Suction Cleaner is priced affordably and gives you a lot of convenient benefits. It can clean the deep areas of large pools without getting lost. It can climb over uneven surfaces and obstacles in the water because of its 4-wheel drive transmission. Best of all, it has 3 interchangeable throats which let it handle larger pieces of debris without getting clogged. We made it our number 1 recommended suction cleaner.

2. Hayward Poolvergnuegen 896584000-013

Pool Cleaner Automatic Suction Pool Vacuum, 2-Wheel, White

Pool Vacuum 2 Wheels

Adapting Turbine Vanes works with all types of floor types 


  • Ability to move allows large debris
  • Maintains constant suction
  • Tire treads for enhanced climbing
  • Internal steering for full pool coverage


  • Design could look more attractive

Why we chose it

This Hayward pool vacuum device is a 2-wheel drive cleaner. Its turbine vanes are strong and self-adjusting, giving it added cleaning efficiency. The cleaner has patented tire treads which let it climb the pool’s obstacles and walls without much hassle. Uneven surfaces are not a problem for the tire treads either. Suction is improved in these areas too, due to the adjustable roller skirt feature.

There are many steering sequences which are preprogrammed into this cleaner. The cleaning pattern can also be random as well. Every bit of debris, dust, and dirt is eliminated by this cleaner. Don’t worry about large debris like log palm leaves because it won’t clog this cleaner like it does others.

3. Baracuda G3 W03000 Advanced Suction Side Automatic Cleaner

Side Automatic Pool Cleaner

Works all floor types

Grabs small and medium debris


  • Simple installation
  • Pump action automatic cleaner 
  • No problems passing over drain covers
  • Only one moving part


  • Gets stuck in pool steps 

Why we chose it

The Baracuda G3 W03000 is strong and pump action suction cleaner. Only One Moving Part allow it to be effective than most other cleaners. Virtually any debris in the water will be eliminated by this cleaner. It can clean your pool’s walls, and floor very quickly.

The cleaner features a FlowKeeper Valve which automates its cleaning performance and manages the flow of water. It is also resistant to scuffs and marks if it were to bump into a hard object. Cleaning around tight corners won’t be a problem either, thanks to its wheel deflector technology.

Perhaps the most impressive innovation of the Baracuda G3 W03000 is its 36-Fin Disc technology. This allows it to move better on the surface of the pool. Just be prepared for the regular maintenance that the cleaner will require, especially after it has cleaned a pool.

Long leaves may be a problem for this cleaner. You should also use caution when cleaning an anti-vortex main drain that is elevated.


The Baracuda G3 W03000 is not too expensive, and it cleans pools satisfactorily. For a decent purchase price, you get a cleaner with many helpful features, such as a 36-Fin Disc, long-lasting diaphragm, and a FlowKeeper valve. 

Polaris Vac-Sweep 3900 Sport Pressure Side Cleaner

pressure side pool cleaner
Polaris 3900 Sport

Only for side cleaner

Runs off a booster pump


  • Excellent sweeping ability
  • Auto-reverse technology, allows it to free itself if it becomes stuck
  • Works in all in-ground pools
  • 31-foot feed hose included


  • Runs off a booster pump (available separately)

Why we chose it

Many people say the Polaris Vac-Sweep 3900 Sport is the top pressure side cleaner because of how well it performs. The cleaner has an all-wheel PosiDrive system which generates additional torque to clean better and reduce hang-ups. It is recommended for virtually any in-ground swimming pool. If you want the best results possible, use a booster pump.

It has a 2.5” vacuum inlet which boosts its performance. What is even better is its triple-jet suction ability. With this design, extra filtration can be added to capture bigger pieces of debris with little risk of clogging. Its SuperBag is a zippered bag with two chambers which stores all this huge debris. And if the cleaner ever gets stuck, its advanced auto-reverse technology will assist in getting it unstuck.

The Polaris Vac-Sweep 3900 comes with the TailSweep PRO, which is an innovative hose improvement to help eliminate debris and dirt from each corner of the swimming pool. The 31-foot hose kit is a nice included feature, but the hose connections themselves are not the best quality.


The Polaris Vac-Sweep 3900 is an efficient and fast cleaner which works great on in-ground swimming pools if you have a booster pump. The filtration won’t clog and can handle big debris. 

XtremePowerUS Vacuum Generic Cleaner


Adjustable cleaner 

Ten hoses included for up to 30′ swimming pool


  • Compatible with the current filtration system
  • 12-pound weight
  • makes it portable
    Easy to use


  • Not good at climbing walls
  • Low-quality materiel and hoses

Why we chose it

The XtremePowerUS Vacuum-Generic Cleaner can handle most pool surfaces, such as concrete, fiberglass, and vinyl surfaces. It has great performance efficiency and build quality too. However, you cannot replace the parts of the cleaner once they go bad. On the upside, you’ll rarely need to repair or maintain the cleaner.

To activate the cleaner, it must be connected to the filtration system of the pool. Even though it can clean walls, it tends to get stuck quite often on them. Removing large leaves from the pool will prove to be difficult too. Of course, this is a standard model cleaner which is why it is priced so affordable. It is recommended to use on smaller pools that are between 16 and 32 feet. There are no impressive advanced features with this model, such as a weekly timer or smart navigation. If you want those things, then you’ll need a different cleaner.

What Does a Pool Cleaner Do?

Dirty pools are not pleasant to be in. However, it can be a challenge to clean the water in your pool. Fortunately, there are innovative technological devices called cleaners which can save the day.

A cleaner is nothing more than a vacuum device which cleans twigs, debris, leaves, dirt, and other contaminants from the water of your pool. This can be an automated or manual cleaner too.

Swimming cleaners exist because of two technologies; water filters and cistern cleaners. The latter cleans cisterns, which are water resistant containers used for storing rainwater and other liquid.

John E. Pattison was the original inventor of the cleaner. This dates back to the early 1980s. He created a device which utilized the water pressure’s suction power to remove sediment and debris from the water without having to drain it. The evolution of this invention turned into the cleaners that everyone uses today.

Picking the Best Pool Sweepers

The cleaner you choose depends on the shape and size of your swimming pool. You must also consider the common type of debris that you need to clean and your overall budget.

Ask yourself these questions:

  • Do you have an in-ground or above ground swimming pool? What is the material? A cleaner made for cleaning vinyl pools won’t be good for cleaning concrete pools, and vice versa.
  • What kind of debris normally falls into your pool?
  • Will you be upgrading or replacing your cleaner?
  • Do you prefer manual or automated?
  • How much can you spend? Can you afford the general cost of a cleaner, which is anywhere from $100 to $800
  • What are the operational costs per month?
  • What features of a cleaner are the best for you?

Three Types of Automatic Pool Cleaners

The three main types of cleaners are pressure, robotic, and suction cleaners. There are good and bad things associated with each one. To choose the best cleaner for your pool, you need to examine the advantages and disadvantages of each type of cleaner.

Suction Side

Suction side swimming cleaners are attached to the pool circulation system’s suction side. The force power in which the suction generates is used to propel the cleaner throughout the pool. Meanwhile, the pool surface gets scrubbed, and various sediments are removed from the water, including pebbles and leaves.


• Easy to maintain and repair; few moving components
• Inexpensive
• Lasts a long time


• Additional wear and tear to the filter
• Must have an activate poop pump for cleaners to function. This creates a higher cost.

Pressure Side

Pressure side cleaners are also referred to as booster pumps. The pool circulation system’s pressure side is where this cleaner gets attached to. When water enters the swimming pool, the pressure causes the cleaner to get pushed around. It removes debris and dirt as it moves through the pool water.

An extra booster pump is required for some models. Fortunately, there is no reliance on the filtration system of the pool here. You just use the filtration bag that comes with it to gather debris.


• Easy to maintain and repair.
• Inexpensive
• Pool filter is not put under extra pressure.


• Another booster pump may be needed.
• Must have an activate poop pump for cleaners to function. This creates a higher cost.

Robotic Cleaners

Robotic cleaners run on electricity. Your other pool equipment is not pressured so much. This means it doesn’t get worn down as much. Robotic cleaners are automated, so manual work is not needed for the most part.

Certain robotic cleaner models can clean stairs, walls, and waterlines. You just need to choose the right model for your needs.


• Good energy efficiency
• Cleaning is easy and no hassle
• Cleans all areas of the pool; stairs, wall, floor, and cove.
• Pool circulation equipment is not worn down so much.


• More expensive
• Lots of moving parts = Additional maintenance
• Must clean filter regularly

Installing a Pool Vacuum Cleaner

The installation instructions are different for every type of cleaner. Just be sure your pool water is clean first before you install your cleaner. This also means having a clean pump basket and filter too.

If you have a suction cleaner, the turn line fittings must be turned down. Connect the hose to the dedicated filter line and then place it under the pool water. Let it fill up.

The hose should have no air in it. After you’re sure of this, connect the hose to the flow gauge. Test the flow and make adjustments where necessary.

Put the cleaner in the pool water. Once the bubbles don’t come out anymore, use the quick connector to connect the cleaner and hose.

Robotic cleaners are very easy to install. Just plug the cleaner into a power outlet and then place it under water.

With any cleaner, look in the instruction manual to see what it says about the installation. That is always the best advice to follow.

Advantages of a Pool Sunction Cleaner

There are benefits to every cleaner. Here are their common benefits:

• Helps prevent water loss
• Water becomes very clear, enhancing the beauty and health of it.
• Save energy on automatic cleaners.
• There are no monthly expenses associated with manual cleaners.
• Save money by not hiring professional cleaners.

Frequently Asked Questions

It is recommended to clean your pool once per week. However, it really depends on the type of cleaner you have, the type of debris you regularly receive, and the size of your pool. At a minimum, clean your pool every 2 to 3 weeks.

Again, it depends on the type of cleaner and the size of your pool. If you aren’t afraid to spend the money, the automation of a robotic cleaner is better.

Depends on the location and size of the pool. A public pool gets drained of its water about 2 times per year. An in-ground pool on residential property can be drained about every 4 to 7 years. As for above ground swimming pools, that water can be drained every 2 to 3 years.

Only time recommended time to turn of or disconnect a cleaner is when their is a heavy storm to avoid clogging or it is not working properly. 


Out of all these cleaners, the most recommended one is the Hayward Poolvergnuegen 896584000-013 The Cleaner. We have installed them on over 200 pools in Calfornia, and by far we found it to be the best performer at of all the other brands, but you should still check out the other cleaners because they might have features which are better for your needs. Their price might be better for you too. And, of course, check out the Amazon customer feedback on the cleaners you’re interested in.